You Can’t Teach Your Dog Things That Aren’t True
“When can we take off the e-collar?” This is our favorite question. NOT! It is actually a very good question. And the answer is simple for most dog owners, especially since they aren’t dog trainers—you can take it off when you don’t want your dog to listen.
Can you teach your dog to listen and behave all the time regardless of whether or not the ecollar is on? Sure. But most people aren’t going to have the skill or follow the instructions carefully enough to achieve that. You absolutely can, though, in most cases. Some dogs are easier than others too, which is also an important factor. Some dogs are very soft and much less likely to push established boundaries. Some will test you daily.
But we are talking about what must be true to move AWAY from your ecollar.
Love the show? Sign up to access our new exciting Xtra content! This content is unique and is ONLY available to our paid subscribers.
Subscriptions are only $3/month! You can also just sign up to make a small donation monthly if you want to support the podcast. Or, if you can’t do that right now, just hit subscribe in your favorite app and tell a friend about the show!
Any support in any form from our listeners is sooo appreciated! We count on listeners like you to help us keep putting out content. Visit the link below to subscribe or donate.
I want to hear from you! Email me directly to ask your questions and suggest topics for the podcast.
Visit our website where you can purchase our online course for only $99 and get started with e-collar training today! Work at your own pace. This is a very beginner friendly course. You can also sign up for training with Kati and Joyce, visit our shop for our branded merchandise and purchase E-collar Technologies collars.
Visit our social media for free training videos and to connect with us!
https://www.facebook.com/diamondk9dogtraining
Minute-by-Minute Breakdown
- 00:00 – Kati opens by asking listeners to subscribe and promises a truth-focused discussion on dog training.
- 02:00 – She introduces the common question about when an e-collar can be removed.
- 03:00 – Her short answer is no, because there is no black-and-white timeline for leaving the e-collar behind.
- 04:00 – She says people often fail to follow instructions precisely enough and some dogs require more skill than others.
- 05:00 – Kati argues leaving the e-collar on is easier than constantly putting it on and taking it off.
- 06:00 – She says moving away from the e-collar requires the dog to understand why the rules matter.
- 07:00 – Using the e-collar consistently now makes it less necessary later because the dog learns accountability.
- 08:00 – She explains the dog needs consistent, meaningful correction for breaking rules before the tool can fade.
- 09:00 – If corrections never register, the dog has no reason to change and the handler keeps relying on the collar.
- 10:00 – Kati says dogs learn the outcome will stay the same whether or not they see the remote.
- 11:00 – She warns you cannot skip training; the dog must know the behavior without needing the tool present.
- 12:00 – She compares the dog’s risk calculation to choosing a consequence even when punishment might be unlikely.
- 13:00 – The dog must believe the consequence can happen any time, not only when the remote is visible.
- 14:00 – Kati stresses that only the handler can teach these truths; the e-collar itself cannot fix problems.
- 15:00 – She says removing the collar too soon only makes the dog’s compliance temporary and unreliable.
- 18:00 – After a sponsor break, she reiterates that if the collar comes off, the dog should still behave the same.
- 19:00 – She says dogs are excellent at spotting patterns and will test whether rules are actually enforced.
- 20:00 – Kati gives an example of her dog respecting kitchen boundaries even without the remote present.
- 21:00 – She describes how inconsistent enforcement teaches a dog there are many free passes before consequences appear.
- 22:00 – She advises using a meaningful correction for known behaviors so the dog stops testing the boundary.
- 23:00 – If a dog already knows the behavior, the correction should be strong enough to put it to bed.
- 24:00 – She says if the dog still complies without the collar, a different tool can enforce the same rule.
- 25:00 – Kati explains a place-trained dog learns quickly not to break the boundary after repeated corrections.
- 26:00 – If there is no consequence after a test, the unwanted behavior begins regenerating.
- 27:00 – She emphasizes dogs are not robots and will eventually test boundaries again.
- 28:00 – Rewards help build behaviors, but expectations eventually need to be maintained without relying on constant treats.
- 29:00 – She says every dog needs a reason to comply even when the handler is not offering rewards or pressure.
- 30:00 – Kati closes by saying you cannot trick a dog into believing something untrue; they know when accountability is missing.